Negative Numbers, Step by Step

A four-week practice order for adding, subtracting, multiplying and dividing negative numbers, with what each worksheet setting contains and a check for every operation.

By Thomas Lee · Updated

Why negative numbers need their own plan

Most students meet negative numbers after years of arithmetic in which every rule worked the same way: the answer to a subtraction was smaller, and the answer to an addition was larger. Negatives break both habits. 3−(−8)3 - (-8) is larger than 3, and (−5)+(−6)(-5) + (-6) is smaller than either number. Because later topics use negative numbers all the time, a few weeks of steady practice here saves a great deal of confusion later.

The Integers topic page already lists the sign rules and shows a worked example for each operation, so this guide does not repeat them. It adds three things: what the worksheet settings contain, a four-week order, and a quick check for each operation that a student can do without a teacher.

From MathGem's creator. I recommend beginning with a small daily habit, one or two pages of about 10 to 30 problems, and increasing the amount gradually. After the four operations, the focus should move from the number of problems to understanding each new concept.

Before the worksheets

Two things should be in place. The first is a number line that runs past zero in both directions: students should be able to say that −3-3 is to the left of −2-2, and so is smaller. The second is fluent times tables, because multiplication and division on these worksheets are times-table facts with signs attached. Hesitation over 7×87 \times 8 will look like a problem with negatives when it is not.

What the settings contain

  • Addition and subtraction: each number is a whole number from 1 up to the range limit (12, 25 or 50), with a positive or negative sign. Every problem has at least one negative number. On Small, the sums run from −24-24 to 11.
  • More negatives than positives: because the worksheet never shows two positive numbers, about three in four additions have one positive and one negative number, and the rest have two negatives. In subtraction, the number being subtracted is negative in about six problems out of ten, so students practise a−(−b)a - (-b) more than any other shape.
  • Multiplication: the first factor is from 2 to 12 on Small and from 2 to 15 on Medium and Large; the second factor is from 2 to 12. The largest product is 12×12=14412 \times 12 = 144 on Small and 15×12=18015 \times 12 = 180 on Medium and Large.
  • Division: always exact. The divisor and the answer are times-table facts, and the dividend never goes above the range limit. That gives 12 different fact pairs on Small, 38 on Medium and 74 on Large, so Small has less variety and repeats more.
  • Signs in multiplication and division: two positives never appear, so about three in four answers are negative. A student who always guesses "negative" will be right most of the time without doing the sign work, which is a reason to ask for the sign to be written first.

Negative numbers are printed in parentheses, such as (−8)(-8), and answers on the answer sheet use a minus sign in front of the number.

A four-week order

Each week uses one operation on the Small range, with one page a day for four or five days. Week 4 moves to the Medium range. If a week goes badly, repeat it.

  1. Week 1: addition, Small. Have a number line next to the page for the first two days, then put it away. Ask the student to say the answer's sign out loud before calculating. For (−9)+4(-9) + 4, the 9 is bigger and negative, so the answer is negative: −5-5.
  2. Week 2: subtraction, Small. Rewrite each problem as an addition before solving it: 6−(−5)6 - (-5) becomes 6+5=116 + 5 = 11, and (−7)−(−3)(-7) - (-3) becomes (−7)+3=−4(-7) + 3 = -4. Writing the rewritten line down is the habit that matters. Subtraction is usually the operation that needs the most time, so give it the whole week.
  3. Week 3: multiplication, then division, Small. Do multiplication for two days and division for the rest. Ask for the size first, then the sign: (−8)×(−6)(-8) \times (-6) is 48 in size and positive, because the signs match. (−42)÷7(-42) \div 7 is 6 in size and negative.
  4. Week 4: Medium range, all four. Use a different operation each day and finish the week with whichever one was weakest. The larger numbers mostly test arithmetic, so a slip here may be an addition fact rather than a sign.

A check for every operation

Marking from the answer sheet tells a student that an answer is wrong. These checks let them find out for themselves before they look, which is a better habit to carry into algebra.

  • Addition: move along the number line. Start at −9-9, move 4 to the right, and land on −5-5.
  • Subtraction: add the answer back to the number that was subtracted. If (−2)−9=−11(-2) - 9 = -11, then (−11)+9(-11) + 9 must give back −2-2.
  • Multiplication: check the size with the times table and the sign with the matching-signs test.
  • Division: multiply the answer by the divisor. If (−42)÷7=−6(-42) \div 7 = -6, then (−6)×7=−42(-6) \times 7 = -42.

Reading a marked page

When a student gets several problems wrong, look at the signs of the wrong answers before the numbers. A wrong answer with the right size and the wrong sign points to the sign rule. A wrong answer with the wrong size, for example (−13)+(−8)=−5(-13) + (-8) = -5, usually means the student subtracted when both numbers were negative; the rule for two negatives in addition (add the sizes, keep the sign) needs another look. A page where only the subtractions went wrong is a sign to repeat Week 2 before moving on. The Set ID printed on every page matches its answer sheet, so a marked page can be filed and compared later.

When to move on

  • Ready for the Medium range when a Small page of any operation comes out right without the number line.
  • Ready for the next topic when all four operations are accurate on Medium and the student can explain, in a sentence, why subtracting a negative number gives a larger result.

Next comes order of operations, where some answers are negative, and then equations. The equations checklist and the algebra mistakes guide both assume that negative numbers are comfortable, and the summer plan shows how integers fit into a weekly schedule.